Mental health central to temple vandalism case

Mental health is central to the case of Samuela Tawase, as the Suva Magistrate Court prepares to deliver a special verdict over the alleged vandalism of the Samabula Shiv Temple, Suva, last year.

Principal medical officer at St Giles Hospital, Dr Kiran Gaikwad, told the court that Tawase had experienced hallucinations and relapses linked to failing to take prescribed medication.

According to Dr Gaikwad, Tawase reported hearing persistent voices that disrupted his sleep and influenced his behaviour.

During one period of relapse in 2024, he was said to have placed stones on roads and thrown objects, actions consistent with his deteriorating mental condition.

The court heard that on the day of the alleged incident, Tawase had consumed alcohol and acted on what he described as commands from the voices, which he claimed instructed him not to harm others but influenced his actions at the temple.

Dr Gaikwad also testified that Tawase had a pattern of absconding from medical care and had previously displayed unusual behaviour, including public preaching and property damage.

An assessment conducted in July found Tawase unfit to stand trial at the time due to his mental state.

However, a later report by acting senior medical officer Dr Christine Chand found him fit to stand trial following consistent treatment.

Resident Magistrate Yogesh Prasad raised questions about the differing medical opinions, with Dr Gaikwad explaining that Tawase’s condition had stabilised after receiving regular care.

Despite this improvement, Dr Gaikwad maintained that Tawase’s actions during the alleged incident were influenced by his mental illness.

Tawase faces one count of sacrilege and one count of throwing an object. The prosecution is seeking a special verdict, with the State having closed its case.

The matter has been adjourned to April 28. Tawase remains in custody as the court considers whether his mental condition will shape the final outcome.